BID Daily Newsletter
March 16, 2016

BID Daily Newsletter

March 16, 2016

Shelf Stable Deposits

Ranch dressing dates back to the owners of a California dude ranch. Yes, the ranch was named Hidden Valley and they served their guests a special salad topper that combined herbs, mayonnaise and buttermilk. This being the 1950s, the best they could to commercialize their invention was to sell little packets of seasonings which buyers then mixed with their own perishables at home. The breakthrough of Hidden Valley Ranch dressing came in the 1980s after chemists at Clorox (the new owner of the brand), figured out the right combination of preservatives to allow the dairy-heavy dressing to be sold as a "shelf stable" product that could last for 150 days.
While not as tasty as ranch dressing perhaps, when it comes to banking, Basel III has a different definition of stable related to bank deposits. Under new Liquidity Coverage Ratio (LCR) regulations, the largest banks must assess the stability of their deposits in a 30-day market crisis. The goal is to ensure large banks can survive a significant liquidity stress for a full 30 days. This new ratio comes straight from lessons learned out of the credit crisis and the idea is that it also gives management teams and the government more time to deal with things without having to worry about liquidity events during that window.
The good news is that readers of this publication do not have to do this because the LCR applies only to banks with $50B or more in assets. What you do have to deal with however, is that this "best practice" trickles down, that you have at least thought about it on some level and how the big banks change their business model, if at all, to deal with this (along with the potential impact on your business model as a result).
Already, the biggest US banks are dumping hundreds of billions of dollars of deposits in order to comply, according to the Wall Street Journal. That is because certain types of deposits that have been popular at big banks, like commercial deposits not tied to the customer's operations or government deposits, are deemed by LCR rules to be most at risk of flight. That means they need to have very liquid securities or cash offsetting them dollar for dollar otherwise the bank can just send the depositor packing.
While most community banks we know cannot handle a $100mm deposit from a single entity and don't want that sort of concentration risk, there may be some opportunity to capture smaller depositors as a result of the turmoil around this issue.
Consider that the LCR rewards big banks for having retail customer deposits that are part of multiple relationships or tied to checking accounts. Those are viewed as sticky and much less likely to fly away in the short term. That means big banks will seek out these depositors (paying up in rate to do so) and will try to avoid larger depositors (cutting the rate or charging this group of customers even). That means community banks need to have a good handle on deposit relationships and a good understanding of what the big banks are doing that could negatively impact community bank NIM.
As with any regulation, there are winners, losers and plenty of unintended consequences. As the big banks change their business model here, community banks will have to keep an ear to the ground to make sure funding does not shift away to the larger banks. As such, keep sending your teams into the big banks to see what sort of offerings they have on the funding side and change your mix and product offerings as needed to hold onto your market share.
Speaking of share, ranch dressing is now believed to be the most popular salad dressing in America. It shows you what a little bit of stability can do.