Skip to Main Content
PCBB Banc Investment Daily October 03, 2013
Banc Investment Daily
October 03, 2013

No Song Bird

Bluebirds are medium-sized, bug-eating birds of the thrush family found throughout North America. They are notable for their beautiful, bright blue feathers and a light-colored underside. Bluebirds are desirable in your garden because they are voracious insect eaters and any bird that chows down on squash bugs or tomato worms is a fine friend to keep around. Bluebirds have also been adopted into numerous popular songs, like "Over the Rainbow" and have come to symbolize happiness and cheer. May the bluebird of happiness fly up your nose!
There are no such feelings of happiness for bankers when it comes to a different sort of bluebird that is showing up in Walmart stores. "Bluebird" is the name of the service we have discussed previously here being offered by American Express in conjunction with Walmart. While it seems like a prepaid card, Bluebird acts more like a bank account. Bluebird's web site even has proclamations like, "Your Checking and Debit Alternative," and "Loaded with Features. Not Fees". What kind of "alternative" is Bluebird referring to? Is this a bank account? Well, not exactly; it just acts like one. It seems that Walmart is offering financial services through American Express without a bank charter.
One of the first things we note is that they are soliciting government direct deposits like Social Security. The FDIC logo doesn't appear anywhere on the Bluebird site, but you can get more information about that by linking somewhere else. We did that and found the funds are placed into custodial accounts (at Wells Fargo and American Express Centurion Bank) and are insured by the FDIC up to $250,000 in most instances.
That means the Bluebird song brings together the melody of some of the largest companies in the country: Walmart, American Express and secondary custodial service provided by Wells Fargo. All of this helps Walmart offer what are essentially banking services without a bank charter.
But if it is as Bluebird promises, and there really are "no annual, monthly or overdraft fees and no minimum balance" with a few asterisks attached, where do they make money? We took a closer look and found fees are charged for reloading cash on the card, out of network ATMs, MoneyPass ATMs and check ordering. These fees could generate some revenue, but this partnership seems so carefully thought-out that there must be some other motivation. The motivation likely is that this relationship will cost Walmart a great deal less in debit card swipe fees than other debit cards issued by banks. Walmart avoids the price controls of the Dodd Frank Act because Bluebird is neither a debit card nor a cash card, so regulated interchange fees don't apply. There is plenty of discussion that even if Bluebird doesn't bring bank regulators to Walmart's door, it's already rumored to be attracting the attention of the CPFB.
For community bankers, Bluebird (and other services like it) is another reason to be sure your offerings cover what bank customers need. Let's run down the Bluebird features: online bill pay; mobile deposit; ATM access to cash; checking; overdraft protection; direct deposit; account management online or in the Walmart checkout lane (can also make deposits).
It's a comprehensive set of services, but it remains to be seen whether customers flock to Bluebird. In any case, bankers should monitor the real game going on behind cute little blue birds.